Why Wouldn’t She Just Leave? Because Abuse Is About Control, Fear, and Survival – Let’s Shift the Narrative

Every time a story surfaces about a woman experiencing domestic violence, a question almost always follows:

“Why didn’t she just leave?”

It’s asked by news anchors, friends, family members—and sometimes even survivors themselves. This question may seem simple, even logical, to someone looking in from the outside. But when we really examine it, we see that it’s the wrong question entirely. In fact, it’s a question that reinforces misunderstanding, blames the victim, and completely ignores the complex, terrifying reality of abuse.

Let’s be clear: abuse is not just about physical harm—it’s about power, control, and fear. It’s a cycle that systematically breaks down a person’s sense of safety, self-worth, and ability to escape. Asking “why doesn’t she leave?” puts the onus on the victim. It suggests that the responsibility for stopping abuse lies with the person being hurt, rather than the person causing the harm.

It’s time we shift the narrative. Let’s stop asking why she stayed and start asking:

Why was she unsafe to leave? What systems failed her? And what can we do to support survivors instead of judging them?

⸻

Abuse Is About Control, Not Conflict

One of the most persistent misconceptions about domestic violence is that it’s just about a “bad relationship” or “fighting that got out of hand.” But abuse isn’t a mutual disagreement—it’s a calculated effort by one person to dominate and control another.

Abuse can include:

• Physical violence

• Emotional and psychological manipulation

• Financial control

• Isolation from friends and family

• Surveillance and stalking

• Sexual violence

• Threats to harm children, pets, or themselves

Over time, these tactics chip away at a survivor’s independence, making it harder and harder to see a way out. Many survivors aren’t “allowed” to leave—not without serious consequences.

⸻

Fear Is a Survival Mechanism

Survivors often stay because they are afraid, and with good reason.

Research shows that leaving an abusive relationship is the most dangerous time for a survivor. The risk of severe injury or death skyrockets when an abuser senses they are losing control. It’s not just fear of a slap or a shove—it’s fear of being murdered. And tragically, that fear is justified. According to domestic violence experts, over 75% of women killed by their partners are murdered after they attempt to leave or have already left.

But it’s not just fear of physical violence. Survivors fear:

• Losing their children in custody battles

• Being stalked or harassed

• Facing homelessness or financial ruin

• Deportation (especially in immigrant communities)

• Not being believed or supported by law enforcement or courts

• The shame and stigma that society places on victims

These fears aren’t irrational. They are rooted in very real, very common experiences. Survivors weigh the risks and sometimes choose to stay because it seems like the only way to survive.

⸻

Abuse Erodes Self-Worth and Agency

Another piece often overlooked is the psychological toll abuse takes over time. Survivors may become so emotionally worn down that they no longer believe they can leave—or that they even deserve something better.

Abusers often use tactics like:

• Gaslighting (“You’re crazy, that never happened.”)

• Blame-shifting (“You made me do this.”)

• Isolation (“Your family doesn’t care about you like I do.”)

• Love-bombing (“I only act this way because I love you so much.”)

This creates a trauma bond, a psychological attachment rooted in a cycle of abuse followed by affection or apologies. Survivors begin to doubt their own perceptions and become emotionally dependent on their abuser for validation and identity.

So when someone asks, “Why didn’t she just leave?” the answer is: She may not feel like she can. She may not feel like she’s worth saving. She may believe the abuse is her fault.

⸻

The System Often Fails Survivors

Even when survivors find the courage and clarity to leave, the systems that are supposed to protect them often don’t.

• Law enforcement may dismiss their concerns or side with the abuser, especially if the abuser is charismatic or well-connected.

• Courts may grant custody to abusive parents under the false assumption that children need both parents, even if one is violent.

• Shelters may be full or inaccessible, especially for women with disabilities, LGBTQ+ individuals, or those in rural areas.

• Financial aid is limited, and finding housing or employment with a history of abuse can be nearly impossible.

We ask, “Why didn’t she call the police?” But the real question is: What happens when she does—and nothing changes?

⸻

Let’s Shift the Narrative

Instead of asking why a survivor stayed, let’s start asking the right questions:

• What barriers stood in her way?

• How did the abuser maintain control?

• How can we make it safer to leave?

• What support does she need to rebuild her life?

And most importantly:

• Why do we still focus on her actions instead of his?

Domestic violence is not caused by victims staying. It’s caused by abusers choosing to abuse.

⸻

What We Can Do

As individuals, communities, and a society, we need to stop judging survivors and start showing up for them. Here are a few things we can all do:

1. Believe Survivors

When someone discloses abuse, believe them. Listen without judgment. Don’t push them to act before they’re ready. Safety planning is more important than rushed advice.

2. Educate Ourselves and Others

Learn about the signs of abuse and the dynamics of power and control. Challenge myths and misinformation when you hear them.

3. Support Local Shelters and Organizations

Donate time, money, or resources to shelters and domestic violence support services. Advocate for better funding and policies.

4. Hold Abusers Accountable

We must stop excusing abusive behavior with phrases like “He just lost control” or “He had a rough childhood.” Abuse is a choice, and accountability is critical for change.

5. Use Your Voice

If you’re in a position of influence—whether as a teacher, employer, journalist, or legislator—speak out against victim-blaming. Promote policies and narratives that center survivor safety and empowerment.

⸻

Final Thoughts: Survivors Are Not Weak—They’re Brave

Surviving abuse takes extraordinary strength. Staying in an unsafe situation because it’s the safest option is not weakness—it’s a survival strategy.

So the next time someone asks, “Why didn’t she just leave?”

Let’s reframe it:

“What made it so dangerous for her to go—and how can we help change that?”

Because ending domestic violence starts not with judgment, but with understanding.

And shifting the narrative is the first step toward real safety, healing, and justice.

⸻

If you or someone you know is experiencing domestic violence, help is available.

In the U.S., call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 800-799-SAFE (7233) or visit www.thehotline.org for confidential support.

xoxo,

fly girl